What I'm going to suggest has nothing to do with fiberglass...
Seems the trouble lies with the aluminum...
When shaping aluminum...it gets hard and a little brittle...
To keep shaping it without damaging it... Heat is applied to neutralize the tension that built up.
.
To know how much heat to apply , mark a "Sharpie" line on it...
When the line DISAPPEARS... you have neutralized the tension and can continue shaping it.
.
In your case.... If you can use a propane torch "IN-PLACE" , it might help you fasten the piece you already have in place.
Bend a piece of scrap aluminum and test it out... Sharpie and heat
I like the push button propane burners...the larger ones ( $50 ) not the little flame 15 dollar ones...
Make sure anything is COLD when you unscrew anything you heated to stress relieve.
.
Gotta Fly...
.
.