I have been thinking about this since I saw this Youtube video comparing LSA accident rates many month back.

https://youtu.be/iv_rRus-X9k

But yesterday, I received the latest Kitplanes Magazine, where Ron Wanttaja compared accidents rates with engines as a factor, and the data basically show that 2 strokes are safer than auto conversions (which goes against most of the opinions I have heard).

This has lead me back to something that has been bothering me since I started shopping for a plane: How safe or dangerous is the Grumman AA1?

I have heard many opinions, most of them suggesting that the AA1 is a deathtrap, but I have not seen any data to directly compare it to the C150. Where can I find data to make the comparison between aircraft?

I would like to see a data based comparison of many models including (but not limited to):

C150 vs AA1
AA1 vs AA1A/B/C (I have read that the wing makes it a very different plane)
C150 vs Tomahawk
C150 vs Ercoupe (how safe is the "safest plane" from a more modern perspective)
C150 vs C172 (since the C172 is the measuring stick for GA planes)
C172 vs C150