Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 18

Thread: 3rd class medical denied ...

  1. #1

    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Posts
    3

    3rd class medical denied ...

    I have spent this entire summer working my tail off to get my private pilot license. Looking back, I should have dealt with my medical first to make sure there weren't any complications, but I didn't. I fell more and more in love with flying the more immersed I became in it. I was focusing too much on just getting my hours before I have to go back to UCF mid August. The AME that recently conducted my examination flagged two medications I take for a neuropathic pain in my shoulder (Neurontin and Elavil), a residual effect from my Chiari Malformation that was corrected ten years ago...

    The FAA's problem with these meds is that they MIGHT cause drowsiness, although I have been taking them for TEN YEARS and haven't experienced any side effects whatsoever. If anything I need more sleep than I am getting now. This is another reason i waited on the medical; I had been under the impression these medications were virtually side-effect-free. Thing is, I have to take them. The pain is too much without them and according to my neurologist there aren't any substitutes that don't state "drowsiness" as a possible side effect. I understand the FAA's obvious concern with this but as my neurologist explained, my meds only have this slight effect when you first start taking them (when I was 10). I would never consider flying if I thought the safety of myself or anyone else is in jeopardy.

    So even though my AME said to "wait 2-4 weeks to hear from the FAA regarding the necessary information about your condition/medications," what I got instead was the cut and dry denial letter. What is the best way to get past this? Is a reconsideration request a waste of my time? The deadline is August 18th. Also, if I stopped taking these medications (I'm looking into nerve blocks) how should I go about explaining this to the FAA.

    Flying is a major passion of mine and I had hoped to pursue a career in chartering or flying for a regional airline. Obviously these ambitions now seem slightly out of reach... but I won't give up on this because the simple truth remains: I am perfectly capable of safely operating aircraft. Isn't that the point?

    Any advice on the topic or similar experiences would be much appreciated.

  2. #2

    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    251
    If aren't an aopa member, join today. Their medical team does a good job working through these issues. The aopa has a list of allowed medications on their web site. Talk with you doctor if there are alternative medications that may be allowed. That page is interactive, so you can query it from your phone or if your doctor has Internet access while your talking to the doctor. If you want to fly, this is probably your only avenue.
    --
    Bob Leffler
    RV-10 Flying
    www.mykitlog.com/rleffler

  3. #3

    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Posts
    3
    I am a member of AOPA and have contacted them. They said I would need to stop taking the medication for 90 days and then provide a status report from my doctor. Even then a response isn't guaranteed... I would try other neuropathic medications but like I said they all have this same side effect and are prohibited. My only hope is to stop taking the medication and look for other treatments like nerve blocks. It's hard not to get angry/upset about this when I know I am okay to fly. The FAA needs to be a little more lenient about medicals or at the very least provide pilots with a better way of proving that they are safe to fly. I can only imagine how many other kids like me have experienced this same disappointment.

  4. #4

    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Posts
    107

    Medical

    My head hurts thinking about fighting the FAA Medical problem you describe. Too many pilots I know got past this and were put on 'special issuance' and finally got tired of the tests and exams they have to do over and over. They finally said "It isn't worth it" and sold planes and hangars and just quit aviation altogether. Really sad.

    Not trying to show how I am better, but facing turning 80-years old, I began building an ELSA and sold my RV6A. I let my 3rd class medical expire last September and just do the driver's license thing with my PPL.

    I think I made a good decision; but if the FAA approves the EAA/AOPA request to allow DL in lieu of the 3rd class med, then I screwed up because I really liked my RV6A. The ELSA is fine, just not as fast. I flew again this morning...5th time this week ! So at least me and the ELSA are getting a lot of fun together.

    I hope you get your problem sorted out...keep trying, its worth it.

  5. #5
    WeaverJ3Cub's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Location
    Dayton, OH
    Posts
    102
    Tommy, first let me say that I'm very sorry to hear that. That's my worst nightmare as a pilot, and it hurts to read your story.

    The FAA is pretty crazy when it comes to this kind of stuff. However, DON'T give up! My first flight instructor had triple bypass heart surgery after a stress test revealed that his 4 main arteries were 100% to 85% blocked. He was a walking heart attack. A year later, he has his medical back (I'm not sure if it is a Special Issuance or not) and is once again happily flying and instructing. I'm not a doctor, but his condition seems like it is just as bad (if not worse than) yours, so I'm sure you can fight through this.

    Are you a member of AOPAs Pilot Protection Services or did you just call their pilot help number? If not, I'd keep trying the AOPA Medical Services Program. Those guys know what they're doing.

    Maybe someone could correct me, but if you did successfully get your medical, couldn't you just let it expire and fly LSA-only? Of course you'd be giving up the charter/regional airline job, but at least you'd be flying.

    http://lsapilot.beasportpilot.com/ai...pilot-medical/

  6. #6

    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Posts
    3
    Thanks for the sympathy. I just checked out the pilot protection service and will probably invest in that, it looks like they specialize in this area. My understanding of the LSA category is that I'm automatically disqualified because I already have a denied medical. Regardless, I'm going to push for getting my medical approved so I can continue where i left off, even though it will most likely be months before anything gets going. On the positive side of things, my father has a lawyer who deals with aviation issues and also happens to know the FAA manager who addressed the denial letter to me. Maybe this will allow me to skip the waiting period for a response, if we have any luck with her. Fingers crossed!

  7. #7

    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Arkansas
    Posts
    36
    Good luck Tommy. This medical thing, especially for a Class III, is totally out of control, in my opinion. As Wilfred and WeaverJ3Cub said, most people can eventually manage to get a medical, but at what cost?

    You may continue to have issues since you want to pursue a career hauling other people around. Those people being hauled around have a right to have the expectation that "someone in the government" is looking out for them. Kind of like when you go into a high rise building. You expect the engineers who designed the structure to be held to a certain level and that the building won't fall on you while you are in there. There are government entities that oversee the practice of engineering just like there are government entities that oversee the nation's airspace system and its use.

    There are a lot of ways to make a living in aviation besides flying for the airlines or charter. You may want to investigate all your options. Good luck!

  8. #8

    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Posts
    5
    Run, don't walk, to the POA forum and put in a call to Dr. Bruce.

    -Jeff

  9. #9
    WeaverJ3Cub's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Location
    Dayton, OH
    Posts
    102
    Quote Originally Posted by somorris View Post
    There are a lot of ways to make a living in aviation besides flying for the airlines or charter.
    Tommy, somorris has an excellent point there. While people think of the airlines first when considering aviation jobs, there are far more than that. For example, there are two airports near me that operate large skydiving operations, and another private airport about 10 miles from my house that exists for that sole purpose. When I stopped by the private field about a month ago just to say hi, by the time I left, they were pushing hard for me to get my commercial and fly for them during the weekdays. That's just one example, but makes the point, I think.

    Ag flying is always an option too. Looks like fun at least! I don't know where you live, but around here in Ohio, there are ag planes buzzing around all summer.

    Those are just two non-airline jobs that come to mind. I'm sure others will have more....

  10. #10

    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Location
    Brighton, Michigan
    Posts
    4
    I just went through this a couple years ago. I was taking an anti anxiety med and indicated this on the 3rd class medical application. The FAA doctor told me i can't take this type of meds and said I would be denied. Of course a few weeks later, I got the denial letter in the mail. I think it came via certified mail so quite official. I went off the meds and waited 3 months. Went and saw my family doctor and had him write a letter stating that I was off the meds for 3 months and that I was doing fine. I sent this letter to the FAA and within 30 days I got my medical certificate in the mail. They didn't question anything. Once they had the letter, they issued the medical. I did follow up with them on the phone once or twice to make sure they got the letter and if there was any issues with it. I finished out my PPL last year and have been flying a Cherokee 180 ever since. Loving it.

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •